ATMOSPHERE: 4.0/5.0 (friendly vibe, felt like a solid place).
PRICE: 4.0/5.0 (averaged out to a little over $10 a guy).
LOCATION: 4.0/5.0 (easily located in Bexley, good parking).
SERVICE: 2.5/5.0 (not impressed at all).
TASTE: 8.0/5.0 (well done pizza, all of it was good).
BOTTOM LINE: 22.5/30 for Bexley Pizza Plus. Just about everything about this place was either close or right on target. However, we were really turned off when they started to put chairs up on tables on the other side of the dining room. Also had some communication issues ordering. But, we would absolutely not discourage you visiting here. They know how to make pizza and they do it well. Go with the "Steak" or "Mega Meat." Enjoyed them both quite a bit!