Atmosphere: 4.5/5.0 (felt unique, very local and original).
Price: 4.0/5.0 (a little more than the $10 range, but solid).
Location: 3.5/5.0 (a drive from Central Ohio, worth it).
Service: 5.0/5.0 (absolutely on the ball, near perfect).
Taste: 8.5/10 (none of the pizzas we had were bad).
Bottom Line: 25.5/30 is the final score! Really difficult to try to find something negative about this place. Shirky's Pizza Zone is a fantastic little pizza shop with some big taste. All of the pizzas we had were good. While it's a bit of a drive from Central Ohio, you need to make the trek to Carroll and go here. The service was on the ball the entire time (and they were really busy, too). If you go, we recommend the Buffalo Chicken or the Pork Pizza. One of our new faves.